2 Gay Gyms & Spas in Long Island, NY

The cavernous main floor is filled with rows of cardio machines and weight stations, a setup aimed at serious lifters. This New York Sports Club in Garden City also houses a Mind/Body studio with Pilates classes and a functional field for agility work. Recovery lounges are a newer addition, reflecting the brand's shift under CEO Bill McMenamy, who took over in 2022. The gym keeps early hours—opens at 5am weekdays—making it easy for commuters. Weekend hours are shorter, closing at 6pm Saturday and 5pm Sunday. With a 2.8 Yelp rating from 11 reviews, the vibe is utilitarian. If you're nearby, LA Fitness offers another option with different equipment and classes.

In Oyster Bay, LA Fitness is a mainstream gym chain that draws a diverse crowd, including gay men from the nearby community college. It offers a sauna, group classes, and standard cardio and strength equipment. The Yelp rating sits at 2.2 out of five from 119 reviews. Hours are extensive: weekdays from 5am to 11pm, with shorter weekend hours. If you're after serious lifting or social cruising, New York Sports Club is a nearby alternative worth checking out.