Schmackary's
American · Baked Goods · New York, NY
About
A cookie shop might seem like a simple concept, but Schmackary's elevates it with a menu of over 80 rotating cookie flavors and a gay-owned pedigree from a former Broadway performer. The Hell's Kitchen spot pairs whimsical flavors like Maple Bacon and Red Velvet with a fast-casual, family-friendly vibe that's as welcoming as it is creative. Yelp reviewers rave about the unique taste and the staff's midwestern charm, calling the cookies "unbelievable" and a must-try in the theater district.
This isn't just a daytime treat. Schmackary's stays open late, making it a perfect after-dinner stop for dessert and a glass of milk. The shop is dog friendly too, so you can bring your pup along. If you can't visit in person, they ship nationwide, ideal for sending a taste of New York to friends.
Located in Hell's Kitchen, right by the Broadway theater district, it's an easy stop before or after a show.
Features
- ✓Over 80 rotating cookie flavors
- ✓Gay-owned by former Broadway performer
- ✓Open late for after-dinner treats
- ✓Dog-friendly cafe
- ✓Nationwide shipping available
Cuisine
Good for
Practical
What people say
Rated from 39 reviews. 15 community ratings. View this venue on Yelp
From the community
“wow. worth the calories”
The cookies here are genuinely incredible. The Maple Bacon flavor is popular and very good, but I believe many of the others are even better (I purchased a mixed batch, after all). They're a bit expensive for a cookie, but worth it. The place is owned by a gay former theater performer and stays open late, making it a great option for a post-dinner treat.
A visitor · Over a year ago
“The BEST Cookies in NYC”
I have never had anything like this before! The flavors are not only unique and amazing, but the staff, service, and atmosphere are unmatched in New York City. It brings the best of midwestern charm right to the theater district. They ship nationwide and are sure to bring smiles whenever you send them to a friend.
A guest · Over a year ago
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Schmackary's dog friendly? +
Yes, Schmackary's is confirmed dog friendly.
Does Schmackary's have vegetarian options? +
As a cookie shop, most items are likely vegetarian. Specific dietary info is unconfirmed; claim this listing to add.
What are the hours? +
Hours are not currently confirmed. Claim this listing to add them.
Can I order cookies for shipping? +
Yes, Schmackary's ships nationwide, as confirmed by a reviewer.
More Restaurants in New York
Katz's Delicatessen
4.1
Restaurants · $$$ · 2.6 mi
Ippudo
4.1
Restaurants · $$$ · 5.4 mi
Peter Luger Steak House
4
Restaurants · $$$$ · 3.8 mi
Brunch Harlem
Restaurants · $$$ · 3.7 mi