Honeypie Cafe
American · Baked Goods · WI
About
Honeypie Cafe stands out in Milwaukee's restaurant scene by making nearly everything from scratch—pickles, piecrust, and all. This Bay View spot serves Midwestern-inspired comfort food with local ingredients: Wisconsin grass-fed beef burgers, produce from nearby farms, and from-scratch baked goods. The vibe is casual and mixed-gay-straight, with a full bar, happy hour, and outdoor seating. It's a place where you can grab brunch, lunch, or dinner without fuss.
Regulars know the pork fries are a must: fries loaded with pulled pork, jalapenos, cheese sauce, and bacon. The menu also includes items like locally grown salads and homemade strawberry shortcake. Honeypie is open daily 9am-9pm, with 944 Yelp reviews averaging 4.1 stars. If you're exploring further, nearby Stack'd Burger Bar is another local burger spot worth considering.
Honeypie Cafe is located in the Bay View neighborhood, near E Potter Avenue. This area is known for its local eateries and artsy vibe.
Features
- ✓Midwestern scratch cooking with local meats and produce
- ✓Full bar and daily happy hour in a casual setting
- ✓Pork fries: fries with pulled pork, jalapenos, cheese sauce, bacon
- ✓Outdoor seating available for warmer months
- ✓Mixed-gay-straight crowd welcomes everyone
Cuisine
Good for
Practical
What people say
Rated from 944 reviews. 7 community ratings. View this venue on Yelp
From the community
“Honeypie is a real sweetie”
After a lot of walking during Gallery Night, we were craving some kitchen magic. Honey Pie totally delivered! We started with the pork fries: a huge pile of fries covered in BBQ pork, jalapeños, cheese sauce, and bacon. The five of us fought over every sticky bite. Chili, a ham and cheese pasty, locally grown fresh salads...all were excellent. And strawberry shortcake on homemade shortbread for dessert? Unbelievable. This will be a regular stop for us.
A visitor · Over a year ago
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I make reservations? +
Honeypie is a casual cafe with no reservation system mentioned. It's walk-in friendly.
What type of cuisine do they serve? +
Honeypie serves Midwestern-inspired American comfort food, including scratch-made baked goods, sandwiches, and burgers using local ingredients.
Is there a full bar? +
Yes, confirmed by Yelp attributes including full bar and happy hour.
More Restaurants in milwaukee
Mader's
3.7
Restaurants · $$$$ · 3.4 mi
Colectivo Coffee Lakefront
4.4
Restaurants · $$ · 4.0 mi
LuLu Cafe and Bar
4
Restaurants · $$ · 0.6 mi
Hi-Fi Cafe
Restaurants · < 0.1 mi