Gay Bars, Hotels & Venues in Milford, PA — 19 LGBTQ+ Spots

If you're looking for a charming and elegant spot in Milford, Water Wheel Cafe delivers a unique menu blending New American cuisine with Vietnamese influences. The cozy atmosphere and friendly owner make it a welcoming choice for both locals and visitors. Desserts here are a standout, with reviewers calling them to die for. Reservations are recommended for dinner, and Sunday brunch is also available.

Childs Park is open during the Delaware Water Gap Recreation Area's operating season, typically dawn to dusk, and offers an easy hike, swimming, and picnic spots alongside stunning waterfalls. It's a historical site that pairs well with a day exploring nature in the area. The park is LGBTQ+-friendly.

If you're drawn to fantasy-inspired fine art and crafts, this family-owned gallery offers something you won't find elsewhere. Since 1997, father-and-son team John and Edwin Longendorfer have run Golden Fish Gallery, showcasing their own pen-and-ink, watercolor, and acrylic works alongside local Pike County artists. Monthly art shows keep the rotating collection fresh, with pieces ranging from jewelry to mixed media. The gallery is open Tuesday, Wednesday, Friday, and Saturday from 10am to 5pm. It's a small, intimate space where you can often chat with the owners about their creative process. While in Milford, consider stopping by The Artery, another local arts venue, for a broader taste of the area's creative scene.

Near the antiques and trails of Milford, the Milford Dairy Bar has been serving homemade ice cream since 1974. This longtime local shop offers Italian ice, sorbet, smoothies, shakes, floats, and more. They also make their own waffle cones and feature free live music on summer weekend nights. It's a straightforward, family-friendly stop for a sweet treat.

Forget the chain sub shops. Fretta's Italian Food is a proper Italian deli that keeps expat New Yorkers and New Jerseyans happy with top-tier meats, cheeses, and imports. It's fast-food in format but anything but ordinary: huge sandwiches, soups, and salads make for a satisfying casual lunch. The catering menu is impressively extensive, too. This is a no-frills spot where the focus stays on what's inside the sandwich. Regulars know to grab their order and head out, maybe to a nearby park. If you're craving authentic Italian cold cuts without the attitude, Fretta's delivers.

In Milford's historic Hotel Fauchère, the Delmonico Room carries a lineage from one of America's first fine-dining dynasties. Named after the Delmonico brothers (who legend says invented the hamburger sandwich, Eggs Benedict, and the Delmonico steak), this elegant restaurant serves regional American cuisine with European influences. The dining room features a portrait of Louis Fauchère and a display of 1920s menus from grand European restaurants. Dressy attire is expected; reservations are accepted. The Sunday Jazz Brunch (11am-3pm) is a local draw, and the full bar complements the traditional menu. Outdoor seating is available in season. It's small with only three photos and three reviews online, so this is a quiet, under-known spot in the area.

Bar Louis at Hotel Fauchere is an LGBTQ+-owned cocktail lounge inside a historic Relais & Chateaux property that dates back to 1852. The sleek space was designed by architect William Reue to be “subtle, timeless and elegant,” offering signature drinks in a sophisticated atmosphere with dancing. The bar's listed hours run overnight (12am to 12am) every day, unusual for Milford. Dog-friendly and with free wifi, it's a polished stop whether you're staying at the hotel or just passing through.

In the Pocono Mountains, Rainbow Mountain Resort Hotel sits on 25 acres with a mix of buildings dating back to 1906 and the 1940s. This LGBT-friendly resort has been welcoming guests since 1981. It's not fancy — rooms vary from large kings to a smaller option called "the little guy." On site you'll find a restaurant, several bars, a dance club, and a karaoke lounge. Yelp reviews average 2.6 out of 5 from 128 reviews, but note that some visitors enjoy the bar and club. If you're staying nearby, Dimmick Inn is another option in the area. Free wifi is confirmed.

You'll find a friendly, come-as-you-are crowd at Harrington House, a Victorian B&B on Milford's main strip. The innkeeper Adriane runs the place solo, cooking hearty breakfasts and offering local tips. With five working fireplaces and a wrap-around porch, it feels like a home. Rooms all have private baths and king or queen beds. The inn opened in 2008 (it was previously the Hattree Inn). Snacks and coffee are available all day. Outdoor activities in the Delaware Water Highlands are an easy drive from here. If you want a lively bar scene nearby, try the Dimmick Inn just down the street.

Old Lumberyard Antiques is best for anyone who loves digging through a huge, eclectic collection of antiques. Housed in two buildings, it's a proper treasure hunter's dream with a massive array of items to explore. The shop has earned a solid 4.4 rating from 10 Yelp reviews, so it's worth a stop if you're browsing Milford. If you're in the area, you could also check out Forest Hall Antiques nearby.

In downtown Milford, you'll find a co-op of award-winning artists from the tri-state region. The Artery is an integral part of the local art scene, offering works at a range of prices. It's a straightforward spot to browse original art, from paintings to mixed media, all in one gallery.

Raymondskill Falls is the third-tallest waterfall in Pennsylvania, dropping 105 feet over three tiers. This isn't a typical park with paved pathways; it's a natural site that requires a one-mile round-trip hike to see the full cascade. The trail offers up-close views of each tier, making it a rewarding outdoor experience for hikers and nature lovers. The falls are part of the Delaware Water Gap National Recreation Area, so there's a historical and preserved feel to the area. Plan for sturdy shoes and some moderate hiking effort. If you're based in Milford, it's an easy 9-mile drive south. For more cultural exploration, nearby Grey Towers National Historic Site offers a different kind of landmark.

A restored 1852 hotel that once hosted Mae West and several presidents now operates as a dog-friendly LGBTQ-owned getaway. Hotel Fauchere is a Relais & Chateaux property in Milford, PA, owned by longtime activist Sean Strub. It serves as the hub of the town's gay nightlife, hosting two parties per month. The vibe is mixed gay-straight, with outdoor seating and a celebrated Sunday brunch. The hotel offers a fine dining room, a stylish bar, and a private back porch and garden. In-room check-in is arranged before arrival. For a casual bite, head next door to 403 Broad. If you're exploring nearby, the Dimmick Inn is also a local stop. It's short and evocative.

In the historic town of Milford, The Columns offers a small museum dedicated to Pike County history. Its standout artifact is the 'bloody Lincoln flag,' reportedly placed under Lincoln's head after the assassination. You'll find local artifacts alongside this unique piece of national history.

Unlike many galleries that show national or regional work, Bluestone Gallery features only artists from Pike County. You will see blacksmiths, potters, wood turners, glass blowers, and textile artists here. It is a small gallery open Friday through Sunday, making it a weekend destination in Milford.

A reviewer once noted the building's grand staircase leads up to two floors of antiques. Forest Hall Antiques specializes in American, Chinese and European furniture and artwork, making it a destination for serious collectors. The stately setting itself adds to the experience.

Right on Main Street in Milford, the Dimmick Inn is a historic lodging that's been running for over 200 years. Rooms are simple and some have shared bathrooms. Since new owners took over, the focus has shifted to the pub downstairs, which serves steak and seafood. It's a casual, dog-friendly spot with a full bar and free WiFi. The inn takes reservations and offers outdoor seating when the weather cooperates. It's a straightforward choice if you want a historic building and don't need luxury. Consider Hotel Fauchere if you're after a more upscale experience nearby. Yelp rating is 3.5 from 317 reviews, so temper expectations.

Walking into Laurel Villa Country Inn, you're greeted by a garden setting where herbs are grown for the kitchen. The restaurant, family-run since 1945, serves European-inspired cuisine with a focus on seafood. Chef-owner Carl, a Culinary Institute of America graduate, prepares fresh dishes using those yard-grown herbs. His wife Janice runs the front and tends bar. Thursday nights feature craft beers and burgers alongside the regular menu. Dinner is served Thursday through Saturday from 5 PM, with lunch hours on other days. Note that Yelp indicates this venue may be permanently closed, so confirm before visiting.

Grey Towers National Historic Site is the former home of Gifford Pinchot, first Chief of the US Forest Service and two-term Pennsylvania governor. Completed in 1886, this grand estate played a key role in launching the conservation movement. Today, the US Forest Service administers the site, offering guided tours that share the Pinchot family's social, political, and conservation legacy. The mansion's hilltop setting provides sweeping views of the surrounding landscape. Tours run several days a week, and the site also hosts conferences on environmental issues. If you're exploring the area, Raymondskill Falls is a nearby natural attraction worth a stop. Check the schedule before visiting, as hours vary by season. The venue is LGBTQ+ friendly, welcoming all visitors to learn about its historic role in environmental stewardship.