Mangia-Mangia
Italian · Seafood · Key West, FL
About
What sets Mangia-Mangia apart is its loyalty to local regulars, not just tourists. This Italian eatery in Key West's Old Town serves handmade pasta and seafood, drawing a mixed gay and straight crowd. Fresh-to-order dishes and reasonable prices keep tables full.
Sit outside on Margaret Street for a relaxed vibe. The staff is colorful and attentive, and the kitchen is open nightly from 5:30 pm. It's quieter than Duval, so you can actually talk. If you want a post-dinner stop, nearby Santiago's Bodega offers tapas and a lively bar scene.
This is a local's spot in Key West's Old Town, just a few blocks from the Duval Street bustle. You'll find more residents than tourists here.
Features
- ✓Handmade fresh pasta daily
- ✓Seafood pasta with perfectly cooked fish
- ✓Outdoor seating on Margaret Street
- ✓Reasonable prices for Key West
- ✓Attentive, colorful staff
Cuisine
Good for
Practical
What people say
11 community ratings.
From the community
“good food and they proudly display rainbow flag”
I had the seafood pasta, and the house-made pasta was delicious. The seafood was very good and cooked just right. The pasta really stood out. My partner got spaghetti with meat sauce, and the pasta was excellent. The meat sauce was good, but not quite as impressive as the pasta.
A visitor · Over a year ago
“Never a Disappointment Here”
The meals are delicious and affordably priced, the service is careful without being overbearing, and the employees are lively and entertaining. Make sure to check out this wonderful spot on your next visit.
A guest · Over a year ago
“Not a tourist trap”
This spot is a few blocks off Duval St, and you'll see mostly locals. We've been coming here for roughly ten years. The food is always excellent, and it's a pleasant spot. Prices are fair. You should try it.
A recent visitor · Over a year ago
“Perfect out of the way pasta and wine”
A true local hangout for affordable Italian food and unusual wine. Sit outside on the side patio.
A local visitor · Over a year ago
“Pasta the way it should be...”
This is my favorite in Key West. The staff are always nice and welcoming, the food is consistently good, and the portions are huge... I think I've never left any food on my plate.
A visitor · Over a year ago
Frequently Asked Questions
Does Mangia-Mangia have vegetarian options? +
Yes, they offer pasta dishes that can be made vegetarian. Handmade pasta and marinara or primavera are typically available, though specific menu items are not listed.
Is there outdoor seating? +
Yes, Mangia-Mangia offers outdoor seating, confirmed by its tags.
What type of food is served? +
Italian cuisine with a focus on handmade pastas and seafood. All dishes are fresh to order.
More Restaurants in Key West
Blue Heaven
4.3
Restaurants · $$ · 0.5 mi
Santiago's Bodega
4.5
Restaurants · $$ · 0.6 mi
El Siboney Restaurant
4.3
Restaurants · $$ · 0.5 mi
Latitudes
Restaurants · $$$ · 0.7 mi