Mattheessen's
American · Ice Cream · Key West, FL
About
Mattheessen's offers a quieter, more local alternative to Key West's tourist-heavy dessert spots. This Old Town location serves cookies, ice cream, key lime pie, and marble slab fudge, with hours stretching from 9am to midnight daily. It's a budget-friendly stop for American comfort sweets, away from the Duval Street crowds.
If you're craving a full meal, head to Blue Heaven for a classic Key West dinner. But for a late-night sugar fix, Mattheessen's hits the spot without the tourist markups. Note: Yelp data suggests this venue may be permanently closed, so call ahead before making the trip.
Features
- ✓Open 9am to midnight daily
- ✓Two Key West locations — this one is quieter
- ✓Budget-friendly American desserts
Cuisine
Frequently Asked Questions
What type of food does Mattheessen's serve? +
Mattheessen's serves American desserts like cookies, ice cream, key lime pie, and marble slab fudge.
Is Mattheessen's currently open? +
Yelp data suggests this venue may be permanently closed, so please verify before visiting.
More Restaurants in Key West
Blue Heaven
4.3
Restaurants · $$ · 0.5 mi
Santiago's Bodega
4.5
Restaurants · $$ · 0.6 mi
El Siboney Restaurant
4.3
Restaurants · $$ · 1.0 mi
Latitudes
Restaurants · $$$ · < 0.1 mi