The Flaming Buoy Filet Co.
American · Seafood · Key West, FL
About
The Flaming Buoy Filet Co. sits away from the Duval Street bustle, a local's find in Old Town. Owners Scot and Fred personally serve each table, offering light banter and detailed menu explanations. The seafood-focused menu leans American with Caribbean touches, and dishes often carry a spicy kick that justifies the 'Flaming' name. The crowd is largely gay but mixed, and the outdoor seating makes for a relaxed evening.
Dinner runs Wednesday through Monday, with hours starting at 4pm and closing between 9pm and 9:30pm depending on the day. A short wine list complements the food, and the lobster mac & cheese appetizer is a standout. Regulars appreciate the unpretentious vibe and consistent quality. If you're visiting, Blue Heaven nearby also draws a similar crowd for brunch.
The Flaming Buoy Filet Co. is located in Key West's Old Town neighborhood, just off Virginia St. It's a quieter area away from the Duval Street crowds, popular with locals and in-the-know visitors.
Features
- ✓Owners Scot and Fred serve you personally
- ✓Located off Duval Street, away from crowds
- ✓Lobster mac & cheese appetizer praised
- ✓Dishes with a spicy kick
- ✓Outdoor seating in Old Town
Cuisine
Good for
Practical
What people say
Rated from 1,040 reviews. 7 community ratings. View this venue on Yelp
From the community
“Good food, good service, fair wine list”
A group of five of us came for dinner based on other reviews, and we all liked our meals. Some dishes had a bit of spice, which fits the name, and the limited wine list offered some good options.
A visitor · Over a year ago
“perfect for sommeliers and those down with the cause!”
I told myself I wouldn't have wine on this trip since that's my usual thing... but then I found a spot to have some. They got me with the Tokaji. Frustrating!
A guest · Over a year ago
“Must eat here”
This place has amazing food! It's a bit off the main tourist path, so it's chill but still has trendy decor and some of the best food on the island. My partner and I dined here recently; the scallops were perfect, and the pineapple banana curry was the best I've ever had.
A recent visitor · Over a year ago
“Great date night eating”
I'm so happy I came across this restaurant. The owners are the servers and made us feel welcome with light conversation and great menu explanations. We had the lobster mac & cheese appetizer, which was tasty, and our mains were just as good. It feels more like a local spot, so tourists have to be lucky to find it off the main drag. My partner and I felt fortunate. Five stars.
A local visitor · Over a year ago
“mmmmm....filetco”
Owned by gay people!
A visitor · Over a year ago
Frequently Asked Questions
What type of cuisine do they serve? +
The menu focuses on American and seafood with Caribbean influences, as confirmed by Yelp categories.
What are the hours? +
The restaurant is open Monday and Wednesday through Sunday from 4pm to 9pm (9:30pm on Friday and Saturday). Closed on Tuesdays.
More Restaurants in Key West
Blue Heaven
4.3
Restaurants · $$ · 0.6 mi
Santiago's Bodega
4.5
Restaurants · $$ · 0.7 mi
El Siboney Restaurant
4.3
Restaurants · $$ · < 0.1 mi
Latitudes
Restaurants · $$$ · 1.0 mi