Cherry's
Comedy · Cherry Grove, NY
About
Cherry's is the first bar you see stepping off the ferry into Cherry Grove, and it sets the tone with bayfront views and a laid-back, playful vibe. Known for its frozen drinks and the famous mudslides made by longtime bartender Johnny Pool, the bar draws an older, mixed crowd that skews predominantly women at certain times. There's a dance stage, a pool table, and live entertainment or drag shows on the schedule.
Weekend nights and happy hour are the busiest, with the bar staying open until 1am on Fridays and Saturdays. If you want a quieter daytime drink, it's open from 9 or 10am daily. The staff is friendly, and the energy is refreshingly low on attitude.
Cherry's is the first bar you see when arriving by ferry to Cherry Grove, the iconic LGBTQ+ beach community on Fire Island.
Features
- ✓Bayfront views from the ferry stop
- ✓Frozen mudslides by bartender Johnny Pool
- ✓Dance stage and pool table
- ✓Happy hour and weekend night crowds
- ✓Friendly, no-attitude vibe
Good for
Practical
What people say
Rated from 82 reviews. 23 community ratings. View this venue on Yelp
From the community
“The food needs to be better!”
I stopped in for lunch and I'm only reviewing the food. I ordered chicken wings and fries. The wings needed more seasoning, and the fries were average. I'd choose somewhere else to eat next time. However, the staff was pleasant and the view was nice.
A visitor · Over a year ago
“Great Place!”
I've been visiting Cherry's since I first came to Fire Island in college. It remains a low-key spot where you can enjoy a great mudslide, dance on stage or with others. There's rarely any attitude, just a relaxing place to hang out and meet new people. I suggest going for happy hour or on Friday and Saturday nights. The crowd tends to be older, but some younger people are there too, and at certain times it's mostly women, which fits the name. Either way, it's worth a visit.
A guest · Over a year ago
“Always the place to be”
Cherry's is a Cherry Grove landmark and the first place you see when you get off the ferry. It's always a good time with great music, drinks, and bartenders, including the well-known one. You should come try one of their tasty frozen drinks.
A recent visitor · Over a year ago
“A lot of fun”
Cherry's is consistently a great time. The crowd is diverse, but everyone gets along well. It's an excellent spot for dancing, drinking, or simply hanging out on the patio.
A local visitor · Over a year ago
“The Best Bar In The Grove !!!!!!!”
I've worked in and visited this area for 11 years, and ever since the new manager took over, it's been very crowded. The bartenders are both attractive and friendly.
A visitor · Over a year ago
Frequently Asked Questions
Does Cherry's have drag shows? +
Yes, drag shows are part of the regular entertainment lineup. Check their schedule for upcoming performances.
What are the hours? +
Cherry's is open Monday through Thursday from 10am to midnight, Friday and Saturday from 9am to 1am (overnight), and Sunday from 9am to midnight.
Is food served? +
Food is available but reviews are mixed. Some items, like chicken wings and fries, may not be to everyone's taste.
More Bars in Cherry Grove
Low Tea at the Blue Whale
2.3
Bars · $$ · 1.1 mi
Sip·n·Twirl
Bars · 1.1 mi
Pavillion Nightclub (Closed Temporarily)
Bars · 1.1 mi
The Ice Palace
3.3
Bars · $$ · < 0.1 mi