5 Gay-Friendly Restaurants in Fire Island, NY

The crowd at Island Breeze is mixed, but the real draw is the gorgeous South Bay view. This American and seafood cafe serves up dishes that some locals find hit-or-miss, with mentions of heavy Old Bay seasoning and high prices. The vibe is low-key, and the open mic nights with live piano add a touch of local color. If you're staying in Cherry Grove, you might also grab a slice from Cherry Grove Pizza instead. Just be aware that some reviews allege the owners have made homophobic comments, so it's worth going in with your eyes open. The deck seating is prime real estate for sun and water views, especially around sunset. Hours vary by season, so check before you head over. The food quality and service get mixed feedback, but the setting is what keeps people coming back.

Walk into Cherry Grove Pizza and you'll find the only pizza spot on this part of Fire Island. It sits right in the Ice Palace / Grove Hotel complex, close to the other gay bars and restaurants. The pizza itself is solid, and regulars swear by the garlic bread with cheese as a must-order. It's a casual spot where you can grab a quick bite before heading out or a late-night slice after the bars let out. Service is efficient and the staff gets high marks for being friendly. The menu extends beyond pizza to salads and sandwiches, and the chicken parmigiana has its fans. Weekend hours run late, with Friday open until 12:30am and Saturday until 1:30am. It's a reliable stop for a cheap meal without fuss. If you're staying in Cherry Grove, you'll probably end up here more than once.

Pines Bistro & Martini Bar is a Fire Island Pines dinner spot where the menu leans Italian-American and the evening hours run from 6pm to 11pm, six days a week. It's a splurge-worthy choice for visitors who want a sit-down meal with a full martini bar, though recent reviews suggest the food quality has been inconsistent. You'll find a mix of locals and tourists here, dressed up for a night out on the island. The bistro is closed Tuesdays, so plan accordingly if you're staying midweek. With a Yelp average of 3.9 stars from 18 reviews, it's a solid option when you want a proper dinner after a day at the beach.

On the Pines Harbor in Fire Island Pines, this restaurant serves fusion cuisine in a casual beach setting. Weekend Low Tea shifts dinner reservations to 9pm, so plan ahead. The food gets high marks, but service can be slow during busy times. Nighttime brings a party vibe with regular and surprise guests.

You'll find Canteen by the pool in Fire Island Pines, with a view of the incoming ferry. It offers American fare and Sunday brunch in an outdoor setting with a smoking area. The space is LGBTQ-owned and relaxed, perfect for a quick bite or a drink by the water. A single review warns that some items are overpriced and not well-executed, specifically the barbecue chicken wings. Still, the harbor location and poolside seating make it a convenient spot to wait for your ferry or cool off on a hot day.