Cherry Grove Pizza
Pizza · Cherry Grove, NY
About
Walk into Cherry Grove Pizza and you'll find the only pizza spot on this part of Fire Island. It sits right in the Ice Palace / Grove Hotel complex, close to the other gay bars and restaurants. The pizza itself is solid, and regulars swear by the garlic bread with cheese as a must-order. It's a casual spot where you can grab a quick bite before heading out or a late-night slice after the bars let out.
Service is efficient and the staff gets high marks for being friendly. The menu extends beyond pizza to salads and sandwiches, and the chicken parmigiana has its fans. Weekend hours run late, with Friday open until 12:30am and Saturday until 1:30am. It's a reliable stop for a cheap meal without fuss. If you're staying in Cherry Grove, you'll probably end up here more than once.
Features
- ✓Get the garlic bread with cheese
- ✓Open late Friday and Saturday
- ✓Affordable meals for any budget
Cuisine
What people say
Rated from 44 reviews. 11 community ratings. View this venue on Yelp
From the community
“I was pleasantly surprised!”
On Fire Island, the food was just average at the places I tried. I was pleasantly surprised by the good quality of the food I got. For my entree, I had chicken parmigiana, which was very good. It hit the spot and was just what I needed that night. For my appetizer, I got garlic bread with cheese. You absolutely must get the garlic bread with cheese if you go there.
A visitor · Over a year ago
“Good, but not NYC pizza.”
Stopped in several times. Great for a light lunch or a bite before heading home. Staff is efficient, friendly, and cute. Definitely hit the spot. Recommended. Ate here again in June 2010. Not good. Pizza was dry. Also had a bowl of bland lentil soup. Canned would have been better. I would recommend the pizza after a night out drinking though.
A guest · Over a year ago
“Great Pizza”
The pizza was so freaking good: nice flavor and crunchy. The only downside is the price is very high.
A recent visitor · Over a year ago
“BEST PIZZA IN N.Y. AND THEY SELL WINE”
This cozy pizza place is perfect. Sit outside and enjoy a slice or get an Italian meal, really yummy. The staff is part of the family. Look forward to seeing you soon.
A local visitor · Over a year ago
“The Best !!!!”
The owner is such a nice guy and the staff is really cool as well. The pizza is the best. And it is also a great place if you don't have much to spend on meals. Also try another place; the owner is so hot and the food is great. For great seafood and a great view of the ocean you must go to Jumping Jacks. New owners but still number one.
A visitor · Over a year ago
Frequently Asked Questions
Do they have vegetarian options? +
Yes, pizza, salads, and sandwiches are available; garlic bread with cheese is a popular choice.
Is it open late? +
Yes, Friday until 12:30am and Saturday until 1:30am. Other nights close at 10:30pm or 11:30pm.
More Restaurants in Cherry Grove
Island Breeze
3.6
Restaurants · $$$ · 0.9 mi
Pines Bistro & Martini Bar
3.9
Restaurants · $$ · 0.2 mi
The Blue Whale
Restaurants · 0.3 mi
Canteen
Restaurants · $$ · 0.2 mi