Island Breeze
American · Seafood · Cherry Grove, NY
About
The crowd at Island Breeze is mixed, but the real draw is the gorgeous South Bay view. This American and seafood cafe serves up dishes that some locals find hit-or-miss, with mentions of heavy Old Bay seasoning and high prices. The vibe is low-key, and the open mic nights with live piano add a touch of local color. If you're staying in Cherry Grove, you might also grab a slice from Cherry Grove Pizza instead. Just be aware that some reviews allege the owners have made homophobic comments, so it's worth going in with your eyes open.
The deck seating is prime real estate for sun and water views, especially around sunset. Hours vary by season, so check before you head over. The food quality and service get mixed feedback, but the setting is what keeps people coming back.
Features
- ✓South Bay waterfront dining
- ✓Open mic nights with live piano
- ✓Sunset deck seating
Cuisine
Good for
What people say
Rated from 84 reviews. 15 community ratings. View this venue on Yelp
From the community
“Stay away”
Cherry Grove is the best area to hang out. Most visitors there are attractive. However, Island Breeze is an exception — not that the customers are bad, but the management and owners are definitely people you want to avoid because they are homophobic and mock and mistreat gay individuals. Be cautious eating there because I found something scary in my plate and nearly choked on it. There are plenty of other places to eat on the island. Pay attention and stay far away.
A visitor · Over a year ago
“This is the spot!!!”
This place is great. The South Bay view is beautiful. The staff is friendly and welcoming. The night I visited was open-mic night with a live pianist. The food was excellent. I ordered penne with grilled chicken in a creamy tomato sauce. I highly suggest you eat here.
A guest · Over a year ago
“Correct phone # 631-597-9111”
You've given me the wrong number multiple times. The correct number is 631-597-9111.
A recent visitor · Over a year ago
“deli style food not good”
Two of us had lunch and everything we ordered had Old Bay seasoning — it seemed the chef grew up during crab season in Baltimore. We tried dinner the next day and both agreed it was deli-quality food served on a plate but priced four times higher. If this restaurant were on the mainland in Suffolk County, it would shut down quickly. Don't waste your money there.
A local visitor · Over a year ago
“The best meal on the island”
Great staff, very warm and welcoming service with a smile, and most importantly the meals were excellent! Compliments to the chef.
A visitor · Over a year ago
Frequently Asked Questions
What type of food does Island Breeze serve? +
Island Breeze serves American cuisine with a focus on seafood, including sandwiches and seafood dishes.
More Restaurants in Cherry Grove
Cherry Grove Pizza
3.8
Restaurants · $$ · 0.9 mi
Pines Bistro & Martini Bar
3.9
Restaurants · $$ · 1.1 mi
The Blue Whale
Restaurants · 1.1 mi
Canteen
Restaurants · $$ · 1.1 mi