6 Gay Hotels in Fire Island, NY — LGBTQ+ Friendly Stays

The Belvedere's white towers catch your eye as the ferry approaches Cherry Grove. This men-only guesthouse offers clothing-optional pool and sundecks, plus a roof deck and patio. Reviews note friendly staff and a welcoming atmosphere for men seeking male company. The place feels unique and majestic, per one guest. The pool area is the main social hub, but the jacuzzi has drawn complaints about heavy chlorine and cleanliness. Rooms are comfortable, and the vibe is relaxed. It's a short walk to the beach and nearby spots like the Grove Hotel. Plan your trip in summer for the best weather.

Dune Point Guesthouse is open 24/7 for overnight stays, offering 19 rental apartments with full kitchens for guests who prefer to cook their own meals. It's rated 4.6/5 on Yelp, though some reviews note the trade-off between price and space: accommodations are clean and comfortable but can feel small and cramped. The property welcomes pets and has outdoor seating. You'll find the reservation system requires a deposit to hold a spot, and the guesthouse enforces a no-guest policy citing New York occupancy laws. Fire Island overall runs pricey, and Dune Point fits that pattern. If you're looking for alternatives, the nearby Belvedere is another option in Cherry Grove.

This isn't a quiet retreat; it's a party hub. The Grove Hotel sits right next to the Ice Palace, putting you at the center of Cherry Grove's nightlife. Rooms are basic, walls are thin, and there's no TV. The pool area is lively, but noise carries. Backside rooms are quieter than those facing the pool, according to one reviewer. The hotel only operates Friday through Sunday, 11am to 4am, so you're here to be out. If you want sleep, consider the Belvedere instead.

The salt air hits you as you step off the ferry onto the harbor. The Hotel (formerly Hotel Ciel) sits right there in Fire Island Pines, the only true hotel in town. It's a simple beach hotel with a swimming pool and outdoor seating area. But recent reviews paint a disappointing picture. Guests reported that promised amenities like the third-floor lounge and complimentary breakfast coffee were never available. One review called it a dump, noting a room with just a bed and no dresser or TV. At $$ price tier, it's basic but overpromised. If you're looking for reliable accommodation in the Pines, you might consider the nearby Belvedere instead.

Step off the ferry and you're practically at the front door of this beach house turned guesthouse. The Madison Fire Island Pines offers a swimming pool and a hot tub, a nice bonus after a dip in the cold ocean. The beach is just a few steps down the boardwalk, making everything convenient. Rooms are comfortable, but note that housekeeping only happens if you request it. Breakfast is served, though it can run out during the week. For another option nearby, check out the Belvedere.

Froot Falls sits on the edge of Fire Island Pines, its rooftop patio catching the ocean breeze above a crystal clear pool. The crowd here skews 20s through 50s, a mix of nomads, beach bums, and burners looking for an adults-only, men-only stay. The guesthouse has been LGBTQ-owned for over 45 years, and the tagline 'Landmark gay stay' leans into that legacy. But one recent guest, a seasoned Pines vacationer, described arriving to a rundown property with stained upholstery, mildewy smells, and a dirty pool far colder than advertised. The photos online, they said, bore no resemblance to the current state. Low rating and a single review paint a picture that contradicts the description; any booking should come with cautious expectations. The pool is listed as heated, though that guest found it otherwise. If you opt to stay, nearby Belvedere offers another option in the same category.